The series revolves around a blonde vapid aspiring model, Deborah “Deb” Dobkins (played by Brooke D’Orsay), who is killed in a car crash on the way to an audition for The Price Is Right. As her soul enters the gates of Heaven she finds herself being judged by a gatekeeper named Fred (Ben Feldman). He declared her a “zero-zero”, she has performed zero good deeds and zero bad acts during her time on earth due to her shallowness. Deb tries to argue this and sees a note on Fred’s computer precautioning angels from pressing the “return” key.
Deb presses the return key on Fred’s keyboard before he can stop her in hopes of going back to Earth. Deb gets her wish, but is brought back to life in the body of a recently deceased lawyer named Jane Bingum (Brooke Elliott), who died protecting her boss, Jay Parker (Josh Stamberg). Jane is the complete opposite of Deb; she is brilliant, hard-working, charitable, and overweight. Deb finds that Jane also works in the same law firm, Harrison-Parker, as Deb’s boyfriend Grayson Kent (Jackson Hurst).